Jump to content

Lapping Heatsink


Vasto

Recommended Posts

Hey everyone, it's been a while since I posted but I just built a new computer (i7 920) and am in the process of putting it together. I was wondering how much to lap the heatsink. I've heard that making it too shiny is actually detrimental to the heat transfer.

 

What is the recommended grit to go up to? This is on a stock cooler because I currently don't plan on overclocking it too much. (I'm sure hackintosh will cause enough problems for me.)

 

Thanks,

Vasto

 

EDIT: Also, how would Scotchbrite work for lapping? I used it on a copper pipe and it seemed very fine. Either way I'm going to an automotive paint shop tomorrow for sand paper because of other projects.

Edited by Vasto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it isn't the shininess that's the real aim... flatness to maximise the contact between CPU and heatsink is the aim... shininess and reflectivity are by-products and can help judge the flatness

 

you shouldn't use polishing agents really, wet 3M (or similar) sandpaper like 240, 400, 600 is about what I'd consider the minimum... 800, 1200 help a bit more... 1500, 2000+ is more for aesthetics and doesn't really gain any cooling performance... you can get all of these grits at good automotive stores, even the higher ones

 

the only polishing agents I would recommend are industrial grinding powder for lapping... not household cleaning or metal polish products... think grinding compounds with grit ratings rather than polishing sprays or liquids

 

grinding compound would really be if you wanted a mirror finish, and would only really make sense if you are producing your own custom waterblocks or something, and want a special finish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

nrg is right on! Shininess is just for show. The main thing is to sand in stages to at least 1200. 1600 is better, but not by much. 2000 is pretty much just for show.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I lapped my stuff, I taped some sandpaper down to the top of a minifridge. Then you just go over it a few times in each direction and move up a grit. Let the weight do the work.

 

Course, I couldn't lap my Xigmatek much, due to the HDT design.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sometimes I tape the corners of a 1/4 sheet on a heavy (thick), and flat (perfect reflection) mirror...

 

Other times I just wet the paper and encourage it to lay flat lol...

 

I use a drop or two of dishwashing liquid (stuff for in a sink, by hand) to make the water more slippery

 

 

The method in the OCC lapping guide is spot on IMO... except I do many, many more passes, and take 1-3 hours to lap whatever I'm doing... depends what it is as to how much lapping I feel is required (concavity, plating, surface roughness, level of heat transfer, etc, etc)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just lapped my TRUE last night...took 3 hours. I didn't worry about finish, just flatness.

 

It was pretty horrible to start with (very convex). I really wish I had more lower grit sandpaper (I started with 400 grit wet/dry, but I wish I had 200). The copper tends to gum up the sandpaper, as does aluminum.

 

Just take your time. Going to quickly will cause the edges to catch and the heatsink to rock. Not so good for flatness. If I had to do it again I would go 200, 400, 800, maybe 1600 (if I wanted it really smooth). TIM is going to fill in the microscopic gaps, anyways...

 

:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where is a cheap place to buy sand paper? I just went to Sherwin Williams Automotive and they wanted $40 bucks for a pack of 50 sheets. :-O

 

EDIT: 1000 and 1500 grit.

Edited by Vasto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...